10 Cottage Cheese Cookie Recipes Worth Trying (2024)

When it comes to cookies, we often think of butter, sugar, and flour as the holy trinity of ingredients. But have you ever considered adding a twist to this classic trio?

Enter cottage cheese, the unsung hero of cookie-making. So, we’re sharing 10 cottage cheese cookie recipes, as well as providing you with a list of essential tools for your cookie-making adventures and sharing some invaluable tips for baking with this surprising ingredient.

What Are Cottage Cheese Cookies?

Cottage cheese cookies are a delightful departure from the run of the mill cookie recipes. Instead of relying solely on butter for texture and flavor, cottage cheese introduces a subtle tanginess and a moist, tender crumb that practically melts in your mouth. It’s a symphony of flavors that perfectly compliments the sweetness of traditional cookie ingredients.

Bonus: These cookies are not only scrumptious, but they’re also a healthier alternative, offering a boost of protein and calcium. With a moist, tender interior and a golden, slightly crispy exterior, cottage cheese cookies strike a harmonious balance between indulgence and nutrition.

8 Cooking Making Essentials to Invest In

Before embarking on your cottage cheese cookie adventure, make sure you have these essential tools at your disposal:

1. Quality Mixing Bowls – Start by investing in a set of sturdy mixing bowls in various sizes to accommodate different batch sizes and ingredients.
2. Electric Mixer – You want to mix your batter up right. A reliable electric mixer, whether stand or hand-held, will make creaming butter, sugar, and cottage cheese a breeze.
3. Baking Sheets and Parchment Paper – Non-stick baking sheets and parchment paper are invaluable for preventing your cookies from sticking. They will also help to ensure even baking every time.
4. Measuring Cups and Spoons – Precise measurements are crucial in baking, so make sure you have a set of accurate measuring cups and spoons on hand.
5. Cookie Scoop – Don’t forget a cookie scoop. This nifty tool ensures uniform cookie sizes, leading to evenly baked treats.
6. Cooling Racks – Although it may be tempting to eat them right out of the oven, always allow your cookies to cool properly by placing them on wire cooling racks. Doing so will also prevent them from getting soggy.
7. Silicone Spatula – Spatulas are an amazing versatile kitchen tool. A flexible spatula will help you gently fold in ingredients as well as scrape down the sides of your mixing bowl.
8. Quality Ingredients – It goes without saying that fresh is best. Using fresh, high-quality ingredients will help you achieve optimum results. This includes butter, flour, eggs, and, of course, cottage cheese.

7 Tips for Baking with Cottage Cheese

Now that you’ve gathered your arsenal, let’s delve into some expert tips for baking with cottage cheese:

1. Strain Your Cottage Cheese – To help remove any excess moisture, place your cottage cheese in a fine-mesh strainer and let it drain for about 30 minutes. This step will prevent your cookies from becoming too soggy.
2. Blend it Smooth – For a smoother texture, start by blending your cottage cheese in a food processor or blender before adding it to the dough. This will ensure a more consistent distribution throughout the cookie.
3. Pair it Right – Cottage cheese pairs beautifully with lots of different flavors like lemon, vanilla, cinnamon, and nutmeg. Consider incorporating these flavor elements for a delightful twist on classic recipes.
4. Adjust for Consistency – Depending on the moisture content of your cottage cheese, you may need to adjust the amount of flour in your recipe. Add a little more flour if the dough is too sticky, or a touch of milk if it’s too dry.
5. Refrigerate the Dough – After mixing up your ingredients, let the dough chill in the refrigerator for at least 30 minutes. This will help firm up the mixture and enhance the texture of the cookies.
6. Experiment with Add-Ins – Cottage cheese cookies are incredibly versatile. Feel free to add your favorite nuts, dried fruits, or some chocolate chips to create your very own signature cookie.
7. Watch Your Baking Time – Make sure to keep a close eye on your cookies while they’re in the oven. Due to the moisture content of cottage cheese, they can go from golden to overdone in a matter of minutes.

10 Cottage Cheese Cookie Recipes Worth Trying

1. Cottage Cheese Cookies | Eating Bird Food – High in protein, gluten-free, and low in sugar, these chocolate chip cookies may become your new obsession. Bake up a batch or enjoy the dough right from the bowl – no eggs!
2. Easy Cottage Cheese Cookies | Cookrita – So simple and so sweet, you’ll love these easy-to-make cottage cheese cookies. Enjoy them as a snack or pair them with your favorite tea or coffee.
3. Lemon Cottage Cheese Cookies | Skillets & Pots – With a wonderful cake-like texture, these cookies are tangy and sweet. They would be even more perfect with a lemon glaze drizzle.
4. Cottage Cheese Cherry Kolacky Cookies | Smuckers – This recipe calls for cherry preserves but would work just as well with whatever you have on hand. Sprinkled with powdered sugar, they’re picture perfect.
5. Cottage Cheese Crinkle Cookies | Belfonte – This is not your average crinkle cookie. It’s fudge-y with a soft center and a firm, crackled exterior.
6. Rosemary Cottage Cheese Cookies | World Spice – These cottage cheese cookies are both savory and sweet. The rosemary complements the apricot jam and makes them a festive choice for holiday get-togethers.
7. Gluten-Free Chocolate Pecan Cottage Cheese Cookies | Gay Lea – With chocolate chunks, pecans, and a sprinkle of sea salt, this is a truly decadent gluten-free cookie recipe.
8. Cottage Cheese Double Chocolate Cookies | Cookie Madness – Chocolate lovers, rejoice! These cottage cheese cookies will satisfy your chocolate cravings with a surprising boost of protein.
9. Blueberry Cottage Cheese Cookies | Around My Family Table – No one will ever guess that there’s cottage cheese in these cookies. You’ll love the flaky dough, sweet blueberry jam, and sweetened coconut.
10. Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cottage Cheese Cookie Dough | Dairy Farmers of Canada – Who says you always need to bake your cookie dough? This recipe proves that cookie dough is a star in its own right.

Cottage cheese cookies are far from ordinary. Armed with the right tools and tips, you’re ready to embark on a cookie-making adventure that’s bound to leave your taste buds dancing with joy. So, grab your apron, preheat the oven, and get baking with these cottage cheese cookie recipes.

This post contains affiliate links.

If you loved this list of delicious cottage cheese cookie recipes, please share it on Pinterest!

And if you’re looking for more tasty recipes, please follow our Food board!